[icemaster]

If you could have a lake you could go to and usually catch fish you actually wanted to eat, what would be in there?

 

[IFSHDOU2?]

1) Swordfish
2) Mahi Mahi
3) Walleye

 

[James]

Crab, Lobster, and Shrimp

 

[pistoldog]

Walleye
Crappie
Bluegill

 

[Opry99er]

1) Bluegill (or hybrid)
2) Crappie
3) 10'000 ft+ elevation brookie
4) Yellow Perch
5) Walleye

 

[dieseldoctor]

Walleye
Catfish
Perch

 

[littlemac]

perch, favorite to eat. smallmouth favorite to catch

 

[Opry99er]

Ah hell, if we're talking about favorite fish to CATCH, my list is completely obsolete.

 

[kastmisser]

Bluegill , deep fried fillets with cornflake crumbs.

 

[troutnut]

Sea trout and Lake trout.

 

[fishboycarl]

Gills and Walleye

 

[the limey]

Halibut, cod, walleye and lake trout

 

[Grumpie.]

Do i need to answer this one? Lmao

 

[catman1979]

In fantasy land (fresh/salt):
Shark (that has lobster riding them like cowboys)
Halibut
Sockeye Salmon

In reality (CO):
Channel Cat
Wiper
Walleye

 

[jkaboom]

Walleye (though I totally suck at catching them but learning)
Slab Crappie
Pink/orange/red (i.e. 11 mile/Antero) trout

 

[taogden]

Wipers, walleye, bass, white fish, decent sized yellow perch

 

[tal0362]

IMO it should be a salt water, fresh water question... top three in each category, catch, and eat.... 12 fish total, maybe one fish hit two categories. Tuna or Salmon for instance, with no subdividing ie, Coho, King, Atlantic etc.

Saltwater Catch,
Saltwater Eat,
Fresh Water Catch,
Fresh Water Eat.

 

[chris]

Holy crap its talo! Welcome back you were missed!

 

[redleader]

IMO it should be a salt water, fresh water question... top three in each category, catch, and eat.... 12 fish total, maybe one fish hit two categories. Tuna or Salmon for instance, with no subdividing ie, Coho, King, Atlantic etc.

Saltwater Catch,
Saltwater Eat,
Fresh Water Catch,
Fresh Water Eat.

Saltwater catch- Marlin,Tuna, king salmon
Saltwater eat- Tuna, king salmon, halibut
Freshwater catch-lake trout, northern pike, stripers
Freshwater eat- walleye, perch, crappie

 

[baetisrun1]

salt water catch-Rooster, sword, and dorado
salt water eat- halibut, king salmon, and sword
fresh catch-Laker, pike, wiper
fresh eat- walleye, perch, pike