It has been kind of interesting this year...I primarily stick to jig and minnow or bare hook and minnow early for walleyes (unless I am working the rip rap with a plug) but I have used some of the Gulp Jig bodies with a minnow and have had savage hits while nothing happening with the other rod...they may have a winner here...it makes me crazy though that if I forget to remove the Gulp Jig body after fishing it turns to stone is almost impossible to remove...