I use the Hudd Weedless Grass Minnow on Umbrella Rigs depending on the lake and conditions. The only place I have thrown that bait by itself was Horsetooth and they were jumping all over it. That's not saying much though, since the fish in that lake would jump all over a Texas Rigged piece of cat ****. The tail action is very subtle, which I like. I open the gap of the hook just a touch.