I avoid Boedecker because I have seen it dry up to a tiny puddle for two summers now and I have a hard time believing anything survived except maybe the catfish. But if the DOW says it has excellent crappie fishing, well then, it must be true.
Then again, this may be another case of the DOW having their heads up their ... um .... I was going to say, having a case of "cranial endo-rectosis".
Lonetree, on the other hand, should be OK for bass, walleye, wipers and catfish. The problem may just be finding them. This is your typical Colorado bowl-shaped impoundment with almost no fish-holding structure anywhere except a little at the north end, and at the south end when the weeds grow some more. Lonetree has always been a kind of problem for me because it's hard to find the fish, even though I like the lake.