For me, most likely yes, unless there were too many in the fishery. OR, if the fishery was healthy (IE good balance of tigers and prey), and I caught the record, I would keep the record, but only if I was 100% sure it was a record, meaning it obviously has to beat the old one. I'm the same way for pike over 36"- I will keep only the record from any fishery besides lake X or the yampa river, or if the fishery had too many pike over 36"- but none are there to my knowledge...hopefully stagecoach never gets that way. Tangent over.