Don In Denver·
I don't know the answer to that. But I think any intentional destruction of habitat or stream bug life deserves our contempt. My understanding is that that was the reason it was outlawed on the San Juan where the practice got its name. That's the big reason I think it should be considered unethical.fatty said:Don,
Do you know how bad if at all the shuffle messes up the natural habitat for the larvae/nymphs? I think this could be a bigger issue than suckering a few fish to bite.